This Is Going to Hurt: Pain Medication in Training and Racing

Pain is Part of (Running) Life

As an athlete/person, you’re probably familiar with pain. There’s the usual: headache after a night out, a painful bruise after knocking into furniture, a neck ache after “sleeping” on the plane. Then there’s running-related pain which comes in two main flavors: pain during and after workouts, and pain during and after races. 

In this blog, I’m going to review the use of pain medication in training and racing—specifically over-the-counter (OTC) medication that can be picked up without a prescription. If you want to know more about pain medication that requires a prescription, you’ll need to talk to your healthcare provider about what’s safe and effective in your particular situation. As a reminder, I’m a doctor, but I’m not your doctor. 

The most commonly used OTC pain medications in the United States fall into three categories that we’ll review. None of these categories are addictive; you won’t need more to get the same effect if you take them regularly. 

Category 1: Acetaminophen (Tylenol): commonly used for headaches, fever, and minor aches. 

Category 2: Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs (NSAIDs)

  1. Ibuprofen (Advil, Motrin): often used for muscle pain, arthritis, swelling, and menstrual cramps. 

  2. Naproxen (Aleve): longer-lasting than ibuprofen, frequently used for joint, back, and muscle pain.

Category 3: Aspirin: used for mild to moderate pain, fever and inflammation, and to prevent blood clots.

How Do These Medications Work? 

The exact mechanism of how acetaminophen (Tylenol) works is not completely clear (welcome to most of medicine, people). It does inhibit production of inflammation molecules in the brain and spinal cord that cause pain and fever. Importantly: it does not meaningfully reduce inflammation in the rest of the body. We’lll get back to this. Tylenol is metabolized by the liver and does not cause liver damage unless it is used in very high doses. Read and follow the instructions, obviously.

By contrast, NSAIDs inhibit production of the molecules (prostaglandins) that cause inflammation and pain in the body. Important thing about these prostaglandins: they can cause pain (ouch) and they also preserve blood flow to the kidneys and GI tract (good). They help the former (neck ache) but can also harm kidney and bowel function (yikes). Basically, NSAIDs are our frenemy. 

Most people have some form of these medications stashed in their medicine cabinet, backpack, or purse. You can even buy a single dose and put them in your pocket. They come in numerous versions: Advil PM, Motrin, Tylenol Extra Strength, on and on. They’re everywhere. And, if everyone has them and they’re everywhere, then they must be safe, right? 

If the answer were that easy, we wouldn’t be here.

Let’s quickly review why you might want to use an OTC pain medication in certain situations. Masters athletes may want to use NSAIDs for arthritis joint pain or menstrual cramps. NSAIDs work well for menstrual pain because prostaglandins (see above) make the uterus contract hard. And some people are prescribed aspirin as a prophylaxis to prevent blood clots. At a low dose, aspirin does not cause a problem for your gut or kidneys. If you are prescribed aspirin to prevent clots, or for another reason, you should probably continue to do so in training and racing. If you have questions, discuss with your provider. 

A strong caution here: in some cases, these pain medications may not be safe due to underlying medical conditions. For example, people with gastric ulcers or a heart condition requiring certain anti-coagulants should not use NSAIDs. Pregnant people should always speak to their provider about the safety of any medicine during pregnancy. Again, ask your healthcare provider. 

Training: Inflammation Ain’t All Bad

Some forms of inflammation are harmful—100%. But! Some forms of inflammation are a normal and key part of healing, and inflammation can be part of your body’s healthy response to training. What does normal inflammation look like? You feel muscle soreness after a hard effort, or minor pain in your ankle, knee, or foot.

NSAIDs used to be the first line recommendation for aches and pains after exercise and minor strains and sprains. Another option for reducing inflammation and pain is cold, like ice application and cold plunges. Occasionally, using either is okay if you need rapid relief from feelings of pain and soreness. If you just ran a marathon, for example, and you need to walk down stairs to get to work.

But, I’m very pleased to say that cold plunges do not enhance healing and recovery (what could be more miserable after a hard run than freezing your a** off?) and neither do NSAIDs. Used chronically, they can actually be counterproductive by blunting inflammation that is a normal and key part of recovery and training. Removing that soreness isn't necessarily improving your situation; often when you're healing, if you can leave the inflammation alone you'll get recovery benefits. 

I can hear you saying, “Yeah, but what if I’m actually injured?” Good question. We also have inflammation with injury and it can be challenging to tell the difference between more intense tenderness that occasionally occurs during normal training adaptations and an injury. Generally, tenderness that goes away after a few hours or days is a normal adaptation. If pain gets worse with time, or never really goes away, then talk to your provider to see what’s going on. 

Straight-up No: NSAIDs During Racing

In the 1990s, Advil sponsored a 10k race in Central Park called the Advil Mini Marathon. There was ample Advil swag. While they did not give the medication out during the race, the message seemed to be that Advil was a runner’s friend. If Advil reduces pain, and pain slows you down, then why not? Why not indeed. Knowing what we know now, times and recommendations have changed, for the better. 

During racing, NSAIDs like Advil, Motrin and Aleve are a serious no. They're 100% to be avoided before and during racing. Even if you're hydrating, they can be dangerous. Why? It comes down to blood flow. NSAIDs are potent regulators of where blood flow goes. Blood flow is key to our kidney and GI tract functions. When you take NSAIDs, blood flow is diverted away from your kidneys and GI tract. Then what?

Reduced blood flow can cause kidney damage, which can be minor or severe. In some long distance events, NSAID use has been associated with kidney damage so severe as to require hospitalization and even dialysis. NSAIDs also reduce the production of the mucous barrier that protects your GI tract, increasing the risk of bleeding. NSAIDs also can worsen acid reflux. Diverting blood away from the GI tract slows it down and can thereby interfere with processing food and liquids. 

These risks are magnified by dehydration. When you’re exercising, you temporarily have less blood volume overall. Think of blood volume like the Colorado River: A lot of places want it, and you need to decide where it’s going to go. NSAIDs will take blood flow away from your kidneys and GI tract. NSAIDs also increase the risk of the serious conditions rhabdomyolysis and hyponatremia. Are you convinced yet? 

Tylenol is the Safer Option When Racing

Importantly, reconsider taking OTCs to cover up pain at the start of a race; if you need medication before you run, we may have a bigger problem. You should be comfortable at the starting point and shouldn't be taking pain medication in order to run. If something happens mid-race, like stubbing your toe hard on the trail, you could take Tylenol. Tylenol is a much safer medication because it doesn't cause changes that increase the risk of damaging your kidneys or gut. And, if you need pain medication after a race,Tylenol is also going to be the safer choice. 

Training involves repeatedly challenging your muscles and joints as you get stronger, and inflammation is going to be your body’s natural response. Before jumping straight for OTC medication when you have soreness, see if the pain resolves on its own. Your body can benefit. And remember, if your pain does not resolve over time or worsens, see your healthcare provider. 

Reference:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11598303/

Next
Next

It All Begins Here